Yes. I've shot one buck. My father in law has shot 4 or 5 deer in Ohio with them. They seem to do a little more meat damage than other slower moving, heavier 45/70 rounds like the 405Gr Core-Lokt. My buck dropped right in his tracks.Have you or anyone shot any deer with the hornady gummies?
I will continue to shoot them. They are cheap and very accurate in my gun. Many hand loaders prefer the 405gr pills.